The Critic Who Became the Champion
Prefer to listen? Here’s the audio companion for this article.
Not every leader shows up in a way that's easy to appreciate at first.
Sometimes the person with influence is not the one setting the tone you want. Sometimes he is the one sitting in the back of the room, criticizing decisions, going back and forth with employees, and stirring things up more than helping.
I have seen that kind of leader before.
In this case, that is exactly what was happening. He would sit in the back of the room and criticize. He would go back and forth with other employees. People listened to him. He had influence. The problem was he was using that influence the wrong way.
The easy thing to do would have been to label him as a problem and spend all our time trying to shut that down.
But myself and the leadership team saw something else.
We saw that he was already a leader. The issue was not whether he could lead. The issue was how he was leading. He was leading in a negative direction. But we also saw that if we could redirect that, he could become a real asset.
So instead of just treating him like a disruption to manage, we gave him something real to own.
We sent him to DBI training in Red Wing, Minnesota and put fall protection in his hands.
That decision changed everything.
Sometimes the Right Move Is Ownership
One of the biggest mistakes leaders make is assuming criticism always comes from a bad place.
Sometimes it does. But sometimes it comes from somebody who has influence, has strong opinions, and has not been asked to use that influence the right way.
That was the situation here.
This employee had the ability to lead. He could shape the attitude of the people around him just by how he carried himself in the room. The question was whether that influence was going to keep working against us or whether we were willing to redirect it.
Sometimes leadership is not just about correcting behavior. Sometimes it is about recognizing that the person causing friction may be the same person who can help raise the standard if you give him the right responsibility.
That takes judgment. It also takes some courage, because once you hand somebody ownership, you are making a bet on who they can become.
What Happened After the Training
Sending him to DBI was important, but the trip itself was not the whole story.
We were telling him clearly that we trusted him to take something important seriously. We were giving him training, but we were also giving him responsibility.
When he came back from Red Wing, he did not just come back with a certificate or a few talking points. He came back and took ownership.
He took hold of the fall protection program and started helping build an in-house program that fit our operation. He also helped develop tie-off points into our preventive maintenance program, which made fall protection more practical and more built into the work itself.
That is when you know something real has changed. He was no longer sitting in the back criticizing what leadership should do. He was helping build the solution with us.
He Became the Go-To Person
Over time, something else happened that mattered even more.
When employees had questions about fall protection, they went to him.
Not because they were told to. Not because his name was on an org chart. They went to him because he had become the person people trusted for help and support.
To me, that is what a real champion looks like.
He went from being the guy in the back of the room stirring things up to being the person employees went to when they needed help with fall protection.
That is a leadership win. It is also a safety win.
Don't Miss What Is In Front of You
There is an important lesson here for leaders in safety, operations, and maintenance.
Some of the people creating the most frustration in your organization may also be the people with the most leadership potential.
That does not mean every critic should be rewarded. It does not mean bad behavior should be ignored. But it does mean leaders should look deeper before writing someone off completely.
Ask a better question.
Is this person only resisting, or is this somebody with influence who needs direction, ownership, and a chance to lead the right way?
If the answer is yes, then maybe the next step is not to push them further away.
Maybe the next step is to give them something real to carry.
That is what happened here. We saw a man who was already leading, just in the wrong way. We invested in him, gave him responsibility, and watched him become the fall protection champion people relied on.
Not every critic becomes a champion.
But sometimes the person challenging the room is the exact person who can help raise the standard, if leadership is wise enough to see it.
Bryan Barker is an EHS professional with experience across construction, mining, and general industry. True North EHS provides practical safety insight for real-world operations.
